Council of New York Cooperatives & Condominiums
Article Archive
Conference Highlights

Publication Date: Summer 1998

Every autumn, the Council of New York Cooperatives & Condominiums holds its day-long, information-packed Cooperative Housing Conference, where more than 60 workshops and seminars present unequaled opportunities for board members and potential board members of cooperatives and condominiums to learn and to share information on every aspect of operating their buildings. This unparalleled learning experience provides guidance and inspiration to New York cooperators and condo unit owners.

A constant theme of Conference is the importance of preparation and organization in ensuring the success of a board. Summarized below is a workshop presented at the 17th annual Cooperative Housing Conference which guides boards in these areas. In this seminar, attorney and management firm principal Ronni Lynn Arougheti offered insightful guidance for optimizing the effectiveness of board meetings.


Two keys to a successful board meeting are organization and preparation. Without these elements, the board members won't have all the information they need to make decisions, and their meetings can be long, tedious and largely ineffective.

Attorney Ronni Lynn Arougheti, who is president of the management company Heron Ltd., teaches that successful board meetings need a comprehensive agenda and a firm policy of sticking to it.

"A meeting can't be conducted in an informal manner," she says, noting that board members should be cautioned against raising surprise topics during meetings. Instead, topics should be cleared in advance so they can be placed on the agenda, giving colleagues time to consider the matter and prepare questions.

"You have to try to avoid a situation where the meeting is ready to adjourn and a member brings up a new topic that has not been researched, keeping everyone there for another hour," she says.

This doesn't mean that meetings can't occasionally stray onto uncharted -- and potentially useful -- ground. For example, during a board discussion someone may present a new but relevant idea that merits some exploration. "That's fine," says Ms. Arougheti. "What you want to avoid is the board member who is constantly bringing up unrelated new topics and pet projects that are not on the agenda."

A typical board meeting should begin with the property manager's report. This document should detail operations from the time of the previous meeting, and should be presented to each board member in advance of the meeting. Here is where many buildings make a crucial mistake: if the managing agent's report is first presented at the board meeting, board members must digest the information and formulate questions on the spot. This wastes valuable time and could cause important issues to be overlooked.

If the agent provides a succinct written report to every board member at least three days before the meeting, then board members can be required to acquaint themselves with the material and to come to the meeting with pertinent questions. For example, Ms. Arougheti says her firm prepares a written narrative management report that covers everything that went on during the month. She attaches every piece of correspondence, copies of bids and estimates, and other paperwork that pertains to operations. This report is separate from the monthly financial report, which agents should also furnish to board members prior to each meeting.

"This makes the board meeting go much faster, because many questions are answered by simply reading the report," she says. "Having this ahead of time also allows the board to incorporate additional items into the meeting agenda." Other good reasons to have written management reports: they help bring new members up to speed on building issues, and they can be used as an historical reference to back up the corporate minutes by showing when and why decisions and actions were taken.

Sometimes it takes more than one board meeting for a difficult decision to be made. Rather than allow prolonged discussion on a controversial issue, many boards invoke preset limits for debate. When 10 minutes have passed without a consensus being formed, the issue can be referred to a committee or back to the agent for supplementary information for the next report to the board.

Of course, having these reports is of no use unless board members read them -- and, unfortunately, many directors don't, says Ms. Arougheti. "Before you can have an effective meeting, you have to have effective directors," she says. "Many people don't give enough thought to what will be required of them when they get on the board. It takes a lot of time. It means reading financial statements and attending board meetings and other meetings."

She notes that it's the current board's responsibility to educate shareholders and owners about what will be required of them as board members, so "that you can get candidates for the board who are prepared to give what the building needs. If the board is voting on something that is detailed in the management report but you have not read it, how can you expect to make an educated decision? If you read the report at the meeting, then you're delaying the meeting."

Similarly, boards cannot operate efficiently at meetings if members don't attend regularly. When they do come, the rest of the members often fall into the error of taking time to bring them up to speed. One solution to this problem, says Ms. Arougheti, is to set an attendance requirement. "No board can operate effectively if people show up at will," she says. "If someone makes a commitment to serve on the board, they should know that they must attend meetings. And I've found that you will always get better attendance if there is a rule for all meetings." This would apply to board meetings, committee meetings shareholder and annual meetings and special meetings with professionals and contractors.

Your board must decide how strict it wants to be about attendance. For example, some boards stipulate that anyone who misses more than two or three meetings in a year will be asked to resign. Others give more leeway. Of course you can always make exceptions when people have emergencies or other good reasons for missing meetings.

Another way to ensure better attendance is to create a calendar of meeting dates at the beginning of each board year. Don't wait until the end of one board meeting to select a date for the next meeting because "this puts the board in the position of having to work around everyone's schedule, when this one has theater tickets and that one is going on vacation," says Ms. Arougheti. Instead, she recommends selecting a specific meeting date. "Perhaps make it the third Thursday of every month, or every six weeks. This way people can plan their other events around the board meetings, not the other way around. This also helps solve the problem of having a quorum at board meetings."

If board meetings are well organized, with all members fully prepared, there is no reason why they should last more than an hour or an hour and a half, says Ms. Arougheti. "It's all about informed decision-making, not social time or endless debates," she notes. "If socializing is important to your board, first finish the business at hand, then you can take time to chat."


Sign Up Today
Receive CNYC updates and bulletins by email! To sign up, click here and complete the online form.

Now Online
Member Inquiries
Questions & Requests from CNYC Members, to CNYC Members. Click to view.

click to view event details

You may register for CNYC events by calling (212) 496-7400 or by completing the Onlne Registration Form.

CNYC Membership

Is Your Cooperative or Condominium a CNYC Member?

Join Today!

DOT-COOP Registration

Does your building have its "Dot-Coop"? Register by clicking on this button:

250 West 57th Street, Suite 730
New York, NY 10107-0730
Tel: (212) 496-7400
Fax: (212) 580-7801
Membership | About CNYC | Events | Housing Conference | Current Articles | Article Archive | Links | Home | back to top
Copyright © CNYC, 1996-. All Rights Reserved. Policy Statements. Designed & Maintained by LLC